Brent Council has agreed with the Department for Communites and Local Government to put the final Kensal Rise Library planning application decision.
Responding to a member of the public who had requested a call-in to Eric Pickles, Secretary of state,
The National Casework Planning Unit state:
Responding to a member of the public who had requested a call-in to Eric Pickles, Secretary of state,
The National Casework Planning Unit state:
Thank you for your email set out below addressed to the Secretary of State, your email will be passed to my colleague Fiona Hobbs who is already considering this application on behalf of the Secretary of State, and while she is working on the case the council have an agreement with us not issue a decision. I understand from my colleague that Brent council are currently preparing a S106.This is the content of the e-mail:
Dear Secretary of State,
PLANNING APPLICATION 14/0846: FORMER
KENSAL RISE BRANCH LIBRARY, BATHURST GARDENS, LONDON, NW10 5JA - LONDON BOROUGH
OF BRENT
I believe the above application -
granted planning consent on 16 July - should be called in because it
raises issues of more than local importance:
a) the Localism Act 2011, ACV listing
and Community Right to Bid regulations appear to have been incorrectly and
arbitrarily applied by LB Brent LPA:
i) inconsistent, arbitrary application
of Localism Act 2011 to an Asset of Community Value (ASV): points 7 & 8 of the LB Brent LPA case-report (note 1)
state unequivocally that 'the fact that the building is
listed as a Asset of Community [ACV] value is...a material planning
consideration' (7) and 'is also relevant...as a partial change
of use to residential is proposed' (8);
ii) so why did LB Brent LPA's legal
advisor tell the 16 July planning committee that the 2011 Localism Act and ACV
were 'separate legislation and not under the consideration of this committee'
(note 2)?
iii) LB Brent legal
department's failure properly to apply the Community Right to Bid (CRB):
- Kensal Rise Library, subject of
planning application 14/0846, was designated an Asset of Community Value (ACV)
in December 2012;
- the sale contract
for the building wasn't signed until January 2013, ie after ACV-listing,
so the 6-month moratorium bidding process should have been enabled;
but
- LB Brent LPA chose as the sale-date
the earlier date of the Option Agreement (note 3) to purchase the property,
signed in November 2012, ie before ACV-listing. Using this earlier
date, LB Brent LPA argued that the 6-month moratorium on the sale did not
apply.
b) I believe 14/0846 to be,
therefore, a suitable test-case for the proper application of the Localism Act
2011 to ACV-listing:
i) it's widely believed that the Option
Agreement was signed in order to bypass the provisions of the 2011 Localism Act
for a moratorium on the sale of the property's ACV-listing (note 3, para
6.2).
ii) this was, and remains a controversial
sale and change-of-use planning application for one of Brent's few remaining
historic buildings (note 4). The possibly deliberate attempt to bypass the ACV
provisions of the 2011 Localism Act by then-owner All Souls College, Oxford
requires investigation.
The Localism Act/ACV listing and
Community Right to Bid is new legislation with little or no case-law to date. I
urge you, therefore, to exercise your right to call in the application to
ascertain whether correct procedures have been followed.
Notes:
1 http://democracy.brent.gov.uk/documents/s25283/03
Former Kensal Rise Branch Library Bathurst Gardens London NW10 5JA.pdf
2 awaiting
publication of minutes of meeting;
