Guest post by Philip Grant in a personal capacity
The Italianate-style belvedere tower of “Altamira”, beyond the community
garden.
(Photo by Margaret Pratt, May 2023)
Earlier this month, Martin published an open letter, “Brent’s Morland Gardens development, and the
future of the heritage Victorian villa”, which
I had sent to two key Cabinet members, ahead of a decision which is due to be
made on 16 June. On 21 May, I received this reply from Councillor Teo Benea,
the Lead Member for Regeneration:
‘Dear Mr Grant,
Thank you for your open letter to myself and Cllr
Donnelly-Jackson dated 8 May 2025.
I have spoken to officers regarding 1 Morland
Gardens and a decision on the site use options will be proposed for Cabinet’s
consideration at the meeting on Monday 16 June 2025. No decision has been made
on retaining the locally listed Altamira building and Cabinet will only be
asked to consider the proposed site use(s) for Morland Gardens as part of developing
a complementary vision for the Hillside Corridor.
I will ensure that officers consider your letter
and content as part of ongoing work to progress the Cabinet approved site use
option.
Thank you.
Kind regards,
Teo Benea
Cllr for Sudbury ward
Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning & Property’
It was in January 2020 that Brent’s Cabinet approved a recommendation
for the redevelopment of their 1 Morland Gardens site, to provide updated
facilities for the Brent Start college (which had been there since 1995) and
Council homes. Planning Committee approved the plans (by five votes to two)
later that year, including the demolition of the locally-listed Victorian villa
at the heart of the college. But the scheme was so flawed, and so many mistakes
were made in trying to implement it, that the planning consent expired at the
end of October 2023, without construction having begun.
I was told in a letter from Brent’s Director of
Property and Assets in November 2023, under
the heading “An urgent rethink on original proposals”, that:
‘We are always reviewing and updating schemes
across the board as part of our usual governance arrangements, and we are doing
that with even more rigour given the underlying economic conditions. Following
the expiration of the planning permission, the Council is reviewing its options
for the Morland Gardens site, including the Altamira building.’
Despite the
supposed urgency, nothing further was heard, until I sent an open letter to
Brent’s Chief Executive at the end of March 2024, which I shared in a post - Is Brent Council “busy doing nothing”? In response, Brent’s Head of Capital Delivery said: ‘the Council is
continuing to review its options and proposals for the Morland Gardens site. As
soon as the Council has completed the review, it will place the item for
decision onto the Council’s Forward Plan and seek Cabinet’s consideration of
the same.’
This is a
Council-owned site, which has been vacant since early 2022 (apart from six
months when it was occupied by Live-in Guardians). At least they were providing some security for the building, but ever
since they left, nearly two and a half years ago, Brent Council has been paying
a security firm to guard the empty building.
Notice on the security fence around 1 Morland Gardens. (Photo by Margaret Pratt, May 2023)
As part of their
long-running review, Brent have been given plenty of evidence of the high historic and architectural value of the Victorian villa,
and how retaining this locally-listed heritage asset as part of their
redevelopment plans is both a practical proposition and in line with the
Council’s adopted planning policy and historic environment strategy. How can
Officers not yet recommend to Cabinet that this landmark building, part of the
original estate that gave Stonebridge Park its name 150 years ago, should be
retained? I expressed that view in my “open email” reply to the Lead Member for
Regeneration:
‘Dear Councillor Benea,
Thank you for your email, and for updating me on what will be put to
Cabinet on 16 June in respect of Morland Gardens.
I have to say that I am surprised that 'Cabinet will only be asked to
consider the proposed site use(s) for Morland Gardens.'
Council Officers started to consider proposals for the future of the
former Brent Start college site at 1 Morland Gardens in November 2023. I
understood then that they expected to put their recommendations to Cabinet by
around this time in 2024.
By November 2024, they had already decided to recommend that the site
should be used for new Council homes and community facilities, and they put
this out for consultation then, as part of the Bridge Park and Hillside
Corridor exercise:
By March this year, as a result of that consultation, the proposal had
been refined to be 'new Council homes and youth facilities'. I find it hard to
believe that all Brent's Officers can submit to Cabinet, another three months
further on, and more than eighteen months after they started their review, is a
recommendation to confirm that the proposed site use should be new Council
homes and youth facilities!
Given all of the information and views put forward since November 2023,
including as part of the December 2024 consultation exercise, where there was
clear support from community members for the heritage Victorian villa at 1
Morland Gardens to be retained, I would hope that Council Officers could also
recommend that the future redevelopment plans for this Council-owned site should
include retaining the locally-listed building.
A decision on such a recommendation, by Cabinet on 16 June, would give
Officers clearer guidance to progress their Hillside Corridor plans as they
move forward. I hope that you, as Cabinet Member for Regeneration, will ask
Officers to include that in their Report. Thank you.
I am copying this email to Kim Wright, Chief Executive, who could also
ask the relevant Officers to do that, in order to help avoid further
unnecessary delay over this site. Best wishes,
Philip Grant.’
If you agree
that the Victorian villa, “Altamira”, should be retained, there is still time
(until 26 May 2025) to sign the Willesden Local History Society petition calling on Brent Council and its Cabinet to do that. You can add your
signature, if you have not already done that, HERE. Thank you!
Philip Grant.