Guest post by Philip Grant in a personal capacity.
The former Brent Start college at 1 Morland Gardens in October 2023.
In a comment under my 6 October guest post, Morland Gardens – Brent responds to my query over “Why no progress?”, I listed two follow-up questions I’d asked Brent’s Head of Capital Delivery. Here is the first of those questions, and the answer I received:
Q: I hope that Brent Council can get some funding from the GLA's SAHP programme to help finance genuinely affordable homes to rent for local people in housing need, but I was concerned to read that your bid for 1 Morland Gardens has included '65 social rent homes, the same number as was proposed for the previous scheme at the site.' The failed "previous scheme" included construction of a block of flats on land outside 1 Morland Gardens (the Harlesden City Challenge Community Garden) which Brent did not have the legal right to build on, and the demolition of the Victorian heritage building. Please explain why, in these circumstances, a figure of 65 homes at 1 Morland Gardens was chosen for inclusion in the Council's submission to the GLA.
A: The council chose this as an arbitrary figure to include in the GLA SAHP funding application. This figure happens to be the figure that was from the previous scheme. The actual number of homes on the site will be dependent on the suggested quantity of housing the feasibility work identifies is achievable based on the options that are being looked into.
Arbitrary? An English dictionary definition of that word is: ‘based on chance rather than being planned or based on reason.’ I wondered whether that figure of 65 homes was also what the Council was seeking from the consultants, Mott MacDonald, who they’d commissioned to carry out a feasibility study, so I submitted a Freedom of Information Act request. I’ve now received the information (everything I had requested, unlike some where Council Officers seek to hide things they don’t want you to know, claiming that it is not ‘in the public interest’ to disclose that information!), and here is my update on Brent’s Morland Gardens project.
Brent’s initial approach to Mott MacDonald to carry out the feasibility study.
Brent’s initial approach about the study was on 12 May (above), just after the local elections, and you will see from the final line that Mott MacDonald (“MM”) were already the Council’s consultants for its Bridge Park proposals. MM submitted their response as a ‘Feasibility Stage Fee Proposal’ on 24 June, with the amount of fees redacted but with the billing provision: ‘Monthly drawdown sums to be agreed prior to contract execution / start of appointment.’ (I will mention some actual fee payments at the end.) Agreement must have been reached, as a “Kick-off Meeting” between Council Officers and the MM team took place on 19 August.
Extract of key points from MM’s notes of the 19 August 2026 “Kick-off Meeting”.
The study would look at the feasibility of three design options, with the first retaining and reusing the locally listed Victorian villa (“Altamira”), and the other two based on its demolition. All three options include ‘residential accommodation of up to 65 units’, with point 4.7 of the notes stating ‘additional homes may be possible if building heights are increased’!
The youth facilities note at 4.8 discloses that the youth organisation Brent is working with here is the Young Brent Foundation (it was suggested last year that the Barham Park Trust may wrongly have allowed this organisation to occupy part of the former Brent library building at Barham Park rent free for four years). They apparently wish to use part of the Morland Gardens buildings for ‘educational and life skills activities, including technology, financial literacy and cooking.’
When Brent’s Cabinet agreed the future use of 1 Morland Gardens in June 2025, it was for affordable housing and a youth facility. There was no mention of any change from that use in the Bridge Park (with brief mentions of the other “Hillside Corridor” sites) Report to the July 2026 Cabinet meeting. But now the proposals also include a SEND (“Special Educational Needs and Disabilities”) facility. Note 4.9 above showed separate spaces for both primary and secondary pupils, but that was soon reduced to a facility for 15 primary pupils with SEMH (Social, Emotional and Mental Health) needs.
MM’s schedule of accommodation details and space requirements for the 15 primary pupil facility.
The schedule above does not include the rooms for staff use and offices, or circulation space. The total internal floor area needed for the proposed SEND facility at Morland Gardens is calculated as 871 square metres, plus a minimum of 450 square metres of outdoor space. The sympathetic classroom extension to the north side of the restored Victorian villa, when it was converted to become Brent’s adult education college in the mid-1990s, seen beyond the tree in the photograph below, is an excellent example of how this could be done, with the open area in front of it providing the outdoor space (fenced off for the safety and security of the students).
The Victorian villa, with 1990s classroom extension to its right, pictured in June 2023.
If that suggestion was followed, and the heritage building retained, the rooms in the main part of the Victorian villa, as adapted for the college in the 1990s, would provide the necessary space for the proposed youth facility needs. But the site would still need to provide ‘up to 65 homes’! When Brent’s Head of Capital Delivery replied to my first question on 9 October he wrote: ‘The actual number of homes on the site will be dependent on the suggested quantity of housing the feasibility work identifies is achievable ….’
Email from Brent to MM on 1 September 2026.
However, in an email to MM on 1 September, referring to Option 1, the same Council Officer wrote that Option 1 was: ‘retain the locally listed building for SEND and youth facilities and build the 65 homes around the locally listed building.’ This suggests that 65 homes is not just an “arbitrary” or an “up to” figure, but what the Council actually wants delivered on the 1 Morland Gardens site. If that is the case, the findings from the Mott MacDonald study will say that Option 1, retaining the Victorian villa, is NOT feasible.
Providing that many homes at 1 Morland Gardens while retaining the Victorian villa is unlikely to have been feasible even when affordable homes plus a youth facility was the proposal. Adding a special educational needs facility to the mix has made it virtually impossible. I hope I’m wrong, but trying to squeeze too much onto the site was the mistake which Brent made in 2019, which led to the flawed 2020 scheme. That scheme failed. Are they going to make the same mistake again, nearly eight years later?
Philip Grant.
P.S. I said I would mention fee payments at the end. As work began on the feasibility study in August, I expected to see at least some fees included on Brent’s July to September 2026 payments Excel spreadsheet, which can be viewed under “Transparency” on the Council’s website. The two payments shown for Mott MacDonald Ltd in that quarter include £4,222 charged to “SEND expansion”, which probably relates to work on the Morland Gardens study. It could be that the non-SEND work is being included in MM’s payments for their services in the “Bridge Park” category. MM received £83,838 from Brent in the quarter under that heading.






15 comments:
Former London Plan Density Matrix site accommodates 100+ homes.
This building would make a great library, school, adult education or community centre, it might even be great as a combination of all of these, but shouldn't be demolished. It is too beautiful and to demolish and replace with flats...
As said before, study Carlton Granville Centre in South Kilburn by South Kilburn Trust (Brent) and the Meanwhilers. In neighbourhood regeneration year 25 it is being double towered on, and that with Kilburn Tower Wall surrounding it. So, no community centre, at least not one to serve new town 30,000 scale and this local heritage/ soul place for all estate community has been instead Brent butchered.
It was of course an Adult Education Centre until the botched up plan by Labour Councillors which resulted in its relocation at a cost of over £1 million while the aborted work, and failed Labour plans etc have cost another £3 million to date.
Of course had Labour Councillors listened to Philip Grant we would not have many years of delays and £4 million down the drain.
As Philip has demonstrated it is possible to retain the historic Villa and still build suitable housing on part of the site.
So study what has already happened elsewhere in Brent, if you want to avoid the same fate that is. And be awake to meanwhile colonists.
The political ideology that devolved private tenanted tower estates of isolation and separation need no welfare state infrastructure. When you hear welfare cuts that is where these cuts are to happen, by bad growth design baked-in. A to scale community centre for a 30,000 new tenanted town a needless luxury. Lets build towers on it to erase it and here we are at Morland Gardens, the big picture, the long exclusion and the building inequalities game.
From the London Crime News article on South Ballymore (see online).
At (built on top of) the Carlton Centre and Granville Centre, new council homes (two towers) are set to be completed by Ballymore by late 2026 (interesting). However, a community campaign is opposing the redevelopment of the Granville Rec community garden ( which the local public has been locked out of the Granville Road Public Open Space for 2 years), which is planned to be replaced by the new Granville Urban Park ( which has a road going through the middle of it, nice detail). Users of the garden have advocated for the preservation of the biodiverse space (but not for its gates to being unlocked to allow local access rights).
Councillor Matt Kelcher, Brent Council's Cabinet Member for Regeneration and Planning, stated that the programme is vital for creating modern homes and building a new community (what about the exiting estate community of the community-led masterplan of 2004?) He added that the partnership with Ballymore would accelerate the delivery of the final phases. Local Green Party councillors expressed hope that Ballymore would avoid the failings of previous developers, citing issues such as water penetration, damp, mould, and fire safety concerns in earlier phases (and so much more).
Next Steps. The appointment of Ballymore is subject to a call-in period. Following this, the developer is expected to engage with local residents regarding their 10-year social value strategy (sadly its for the entire NW6 post code, so no need to engage with any South Ballymore consumers, nice).
If you look at the two weeks (to date) total evacuation of the three towers in Newham on public safety grounds required. Wouldn't it have made sense for Brent to keep Carlton-Granville at its pre-regeneration grand scale rather than building towers on and diminishing its community asset value?
'Right to community' for the private estate population grow, grow, forever grow zones needs to be established in strongest legal text terms in the new Brent Local Plan. One for the Greens to pursue perhaps?
'Right to community' only being applied to conservation areas of population de-growth is toxic and undermines national resilience and cohesion. While developers like to exclude, other, devolve and disconnect their colonial business zones from surrounding neighbourhoods, state power should legally required that they do not create such 'othered' non places of cheap towers only no hope.
Below is an example of how new homes can need to be evacuated in population growth zones and therefore how valuable cared about ready made, council supported and alive heritage community centres such as Morland can be there to assist and support community in such an event. The images make Morland look as if its being developer wared over and is out of action?
Three towers in Newham;
Residents of an east London apartment complex claim they feel ‘abandoned’ after they were evacuated over a potentially ‘disastrous’ crack in the building.
Two weeks after the evacuation, Metro visited the Royal Gateway development in Canning Town, where ‘risk to life’ warnings have been plastered across three buildings.
Residents likened the estate to a ‘ghost town’ with flats empty and once thriving cafes and businesses in the development closed until further notice.
A construction worker who was outside Sovereign Tower, one of the evacuated buildings, told Metro: ‘As far as I know, there is no work going on. They are still surveying the building. I’m here for a few days to help, that’s all.’
Sovereign, along with Prince Court, Thanet Tower and Vincent Court, is now empty of residents except for a few who have been permitted to return to recover possessions.
FOR INFORMATION:
I was away for several days when my guest post above was published, and not able to use my laptop. Now that I'm back, I sent an open email this afternoon to Brent's Head of Capital Delivery, Chief Executive, and the Cabinet Members for Regeneration & Planning, Education and Housing, with copies to the three Stonebridge Ward councillors. This is the full text of my email:
'Dear Mr Martin (and Ms Wright, and Councillors Kelcher, Rubin and Johnson, for information),
Morland Gardens Feasibility Study
Further to the information on the Feasibility Study, which you provided under EIR, I have had an online article published in response to it. I'm attaching a pdf document copy of the article, for ease of reference and sharing, and the guest post itself (with some comments added) can be seen at:
https://wembleymatters.blogspot.com/2026/11/morland-gardens-update-on-brents.html
Have you now received the Feasibility Study from Mott MacDonald (which was due to be finished by mid-October)? If so, I suspect it will say that Option 1 (the only one of three which would retain the locally listed heritage building) is not feasible. The reason it would say that is because they were invited to provide the same number of homes under each option, which is unrealistic when retaining an existing building on the site, rather than starting with an empty area of land.
If the Council proceeds on the basis that Option 1 is not feasible, it will be making the same mistakes as it made in late 2018 / early 2019, which have led to so much wasted time and money. The two main mistakes are these:
1. Just because the Victorian villa is not Statutorily Listed, Brent's planners took the view that it was not important enough to retain (without, initially, consulting Brent's Heritage Officer, who considered it had a high heritage significance). In fact, "Altamira", as it was named when built 150 years ago, is not only a beautiful landmark building beside the main Harrow Road, it is also an important architectural building, and one that has historical importance to the origins of Stonebridge Park.
2. The second mistake was to seek the inclusion of more homes than were sustainable on a site of this size and location, given its primary use for educational purposes. I agree that Brent does need more genuinely affordable homes, but the number of them for any particular site must be realistic, otherwise the proposed scheme can unravel (as it did last time round!).
As I have written in my article, the Victorian villa would be well suited to the youth facilities needed by the Young Brent Foundation, with the new SEND facility built alongside it on the north side of the site. That would leave enough space for a reasonably sized residential building to the west of the heritage building, but not as many as 65 homes.
What Brent needs for 1 Morland Gardens is the vision shown in the 1990s by those developing plans for Brent's adult education college. With funding from both Brent Council and Harlesden City Challenge, they sympathetically restored the beautiful Italianate style villa and added classrooms and other facilities to provide an inspiring learning centre for their students, proudly shown on the cover of the college's 1995/96 prospectus:
[BACES Brochure 95/96 cover showing Victorian villa just renovated.jpg]
I hope that Council Officers and Cabinet members will take this information into account when considering the findings of the Feasibility Study. Thank you. Best wishes,
Philip Grant.'
Thank you for your comments, Renegade Resident and Cllr. Lorber.
Paul is right about the gross waste of time and Council (effectively our!) money, but there is another "cost" incurred by the Labour Cabinet's rubber stamping of the original Morland Gardens scheme in January 2020, without proper consideration.
Moving the Brent Start college to a "temporary" home meant that plans for around 70 homes at the Twybridge Way site, which received planning consent in May 2020, had to be shelved. Those affordable Council homes, including 13 family-sized houses, could have been built by 2025 at the latest.
Now, because of that flawed 2020 Cabinet decision, no new plans for the Twybridge Way housing site can begin until after Brent Start moves to its proposed new premises as part of the Bridge Park development, and those are not likely to be ready until 2030 at the earliest.
The lock out fences put-up at MG show that it is at massive risk, maybe already handed over in principle to a developer? Like the public lock-out from the council renewed in 2010 Granville Road Public Open Space. Since 2010 first it was lock and neglect, now it is private use keep the locks on, sometimes to public open too over that period since 2010 but not for the last 2 years.
Dear councillors all. How can public lock outs save community assets?
Phillip, you should really take a look at what Ballymore and the Meanwhilers are doing to Carlton-Granville Centre. The estate here is in grief.
I really hope that Stonebridge can protect this similar community better. The Edwardian hall at Granville was a stunner until the GLA funded a staircase bang in the middle of its giant floor space, party over.
FOR INFORMATION 2:
In a "For Information" comment above, I posted the text of an open email I'd sent to Brent Council. This is the reply I received today:
'Dear Philip Grant
RE: FW: Feasibility Study on redevelopment of 1 Morland Gardens, NW10
Thank you for your open email dated 06 November 2026 regarding the feasibility study on redevelopment of 1 Morland Gardens.
The feasibility work remains ongoing and so we are still reviewing all the options and identifying the proposed site uses and their provisions within each option prior to completing the feasibility work and any potential recommended option. This includes proposing an appropriate number of homes on the site for each option which is a point you make in your open email. Like you, the council wants to see more affordable homes delivered across the borough and any options proposed will have deliverability and affordability in mind if/when these are proposed for Cabinet.
I will keep you updated once the feasibility report is concluded and any expected decision on 1 Morland Gardens in due course. In the meantime, I would like to thank you for your ongoing interest in the site and please let me know should you have any further queries.
Yours sincerely
Head of Capital Delivery'
I did have a "further query", over whether the Council has yet received the report from Mott MacDonald, as the wording above was not clear about that. I received a quick response saying that Council Officers are still waiting for that report.
Post a Comment