Wednesday, 19 February 2025

Butt gets a bruising in Alperton by-election. Lib Dems win with increased vote share

 Charlie Clinton (Lib Dem) speaks after vote declaration

 

Charlie Clinton swept to victory in the Alperton by-election yesterday with an increased vote share. The by-election took place in unusual circumstances following the resignation of Anton Georgiou as a result of pressures on his personal life casued by the release from jail of a stalker.

Brent Greens decided not to field a candidate and called on other parties to do the same as a principled stand against violence in public life.  In the event Conservatives and Labour went ahead and Reform joined them.

Cllr Muhammed Butt had allegedly received the news of Georgiou's resignation with glee and Labour threw everything into the campaign. Barry Gardiner MP and Labour councillors joined party members in a huge effort to gain the seat for their 19 year old candidate, daughter of a former councillor.

 

 

Charlie Clinton outside the blue blocks in which he lives opposite Alperton Station

 

 Paul Lorber, Leader of the Liberal Democrat group on Brent Council said:

The stunning victory for Charlie Clinton and the Liberal Democrats is down to the amazing had work by Anton Georgiou and the Lib Dem team for Alperton over many years.

Winning over twice as many votes as Labour was beyond our expectations but shows how much trouble Labour are in since the formation of their Government. Things will get even worse for Labour as they put up taxes and cut services. 

With Charlie's election the Lib Dem Group is back to 3 on Brent Council and we will continue to punch above our weight in challenging the Labour Leadership on the many bad decisions they are making.

We are grateful to the Brent Green Party for their solidarity with Anton Georgiou by not putting up a candidate in Alperton.

 

An ex-Brent Labour Party member reviewed the result for Wembley Matters:

 

As a long-term resident of Brent, an ex-Labour Party member and a lifelong trade unionist I have watched with horror what has been happening in Brent Labour since 2010 when the current administration come into power. I am very aware that the Tory Party austerity policies has put local councils, especially metropolitan boroughs, and Labour controlled ones and suffer financially. However, some of the decisions and direction of travel in Brent have not been what most of us would consider being aligned with Labour Party values, nor for the good of residents.

 

The campaign in Alperton was a prime example of Brent Labour’s lack of care about Labour Party values and the residents they are supposed to represent. 

 

There were several messages spawned by Brent Labour that were untrue and misrepresented.

 

Blaming the LibDems for the general untidiness of the ward, along with fly tipping etc is unbelievable. Brent Labour has the tools at their disposal to sort these issues, not the LibDems, all a LibDem councillor can do is make a noise to Council Officers, whereas, a Brent Labour Councillor, such as they have in Alperton, can request the Leader and Cabinet Member to rectify these issues by directing Council resources to where they are needed in the ward. That didn’t happen, so the mess in Alperton is down to Brent Labour, so electing another one is pointless?

 

Telling us we need Social Housing while allowing all the available land to be turned into either flats for sale, or more likely private rentals is not the way to go. We are told that Brent is supplying hundreds of Affordable Homes, 80% of an unaffordable rent is still too high for Brent’s housing waiting list applicants, as are even London Affordable at is it 60% of the inflated rental values. Then there are the Shared Ownership properties, these are known to be overpriced and very difficult to sell and realise even the original investments for those that buy in.

 

Basically, in the eyes of Brent residents they see Brent Labour as being the out and out supporter and facilitator of their best friends the developers and private landlords (such as many of their own councillors). The Leadership are not shy of accepting gifts (Irvin’s fairs, lunches, receptions and more no doubt) and why would the Council (Barham Trustees, chaired by the Leader) remove the covenant off the park warden buildings in Barham Park for a paltry £200,000?  I look at Ealing Road library forecourt and wonder how they are getting away with that ridiculous occupation. Maybe they know someone?

 

Brent Labour have let Brent’s environmental services decline into an ineffective service while spending ridiculous amounts of money on the Civic Centre, publicity, and other unnecessary spending. There are so many other failings of this Brent Labour led council that are wrong, it is not surprising that residents don’t vote Labour in sufficient numbers anymore, as shown in recent elections, even before the Labour nationally lost a lot of their support over its recent ineptitude. Citing the Labour Government as an issue is partially true, but it is far from the real issue for Labour in Brent, Brent residents need a Council that listens, does the right thing, tells the truth because it is worth telling and represents the electorate first.

 

I really believe that this Labour group believe what they are doing is the right thing and that they lost Alperton because residents don’t understand how wonderful the council is!!!! 

 



23 comments:

Anonymous said...

Congratulations to Paul Lorber and Lib Dem Team for an excellent result. I am confident Charlie will do a good job sticking up for the residents interests in Alperton.

Anonymous said...

Congratulations Charlie- delighted with the result. The Lib Dems are noted for putting their constituents needs first.

Anonymous said...

The people have spoken.

Anonymous said...

Well done Anton. This is testament to your hard work - no one has worked harder than you. A beautiful legacy you leave behind - and one you can always remember fondly.

Anton Georgiou said...

I am so pleased to see this amazing result for Charlie and the Liberal Democrats. He will be a great representative.

It is a bittersweet moment for me, as giving up the seat prematurely was never my intention. I loved being the Councillor for Alperton. And I loved helping our community.

For everyone who has reached out since I resigned - thank you. Your warm words and kind comments have been so appreciated. I am settling well into a new role and still doing what I love most, helping people.

I will always fondly remember my time as a Councillor in Brent - it had its challenges, but I always tried my best to be a strong voice for our area, against a brutish, arrogant Labour administration, led by a bully.

Finally, I want to put on record my thanks to Cllr Paul Lorber for always having my back and being such a role model. His commitment to Brent over so many years is unmatched and I am confident he will lead the Liberal Democrat Group to even greater heights, as he has done before.

I will continue keeping up with Brent politics via Wembley Matters and wish its readers and contributors well as you work to hold the Council to account and campaign for a better Brent for all residents.

Anonymous said...

Saddened by your comments about Brent’s leader which I think are unjust but wish you every success and more peace of mind and happiness in the future.

Anonymous said...

Congratulations, I am so pleased Charlie has won the seat. He will no doubt continue the good work. Anton thank you for your amazing work.

Anonymous said...

Well done Anton!!! Congratulations Charlie, I’m sure you will continue the good work.

Anonymous said...

You've clearly not experienced the worst of Cllr Mo Butt - I have, not pleasant at all 😡

Anonymous said...

Bully Butt got a Beating. Time for the Labour group to grow a spine and depose the dictator

Anonymous said...

Charlie has big shoes to fill. He must also recognise he only won because of riding on the coattails of Anton. Only time will tell whether he has the same stamina and wow factor as Anton!

Philip Grant said...

Although I am not a member or supporter of any political party, I hope this result will encourage parties opposed to Labour, and its long-time Leader in Brent (since May 2012!), to prepare well for the local Council elections in May 2026.

Cllr. Muhammed Butt has got too used to power, and there are times when he clearly abuses that power. Some of the Labour members in Brent that he has persuaded to become councillors, and to help keep him in power, are not responding to concerns that residents in their wards try to raise with them. They just seem happy to turn up for a few meetings a year and vote as they are told to.

Opposition parties need to choose good local candidates, and those candidates need to be out in the ward they will be standing for in 2026, and seen to be involved in helping people in those areas, just as any good sitting councillor would do.

Opposition parties will know which areas they have a reasonable chance of winning in, and those where they have no chance of winning. If there is to be a big dent in the Labour majority on Brent Council in May 2026, or even overturning that majority, there will probably need to be some tactical voting.

I know that it goes against the grain for political parties, but as well as working to hold onto existing council seats they need to look at which party has the best chance of taking seats from Labour councillors (especially the unworthy ones I've mentioned above).

If your party is likely to finish third (or worse) in a ward, are you willing to not put up candidates in that ward, and to recommend to "your" voters that they should turn out and vote instead for candidates of the party that came second to Labour last time, and stands a chance of winning in May 2026?

The local elections are still more than 14 months away, but the result in Alperton yesterday should be the the start of a concerted effort by local party politicians (and any independent or residents' association candidates) to bring Brent back into better democratic local government.

Anonymous said...

What is your new role Anton if you don’t mind me asking?

Anonymous said...

Maybe this new councillor will actually be able to serve a full term!

Anonymous said...

Where did you hear Cllr Butt received news of Cllr Georgiou’s resignation “with glee”?

XPH said...

Now if only the rest of Brent can get Labour out! Why do the residents keep voting for Labour? It's time for a change.

Anonymous said...

There are plenty of people, including those in the Labour Party, who want to get rid off the Butt family running Brent through their family connections.

While Butt may have been pleased to see the back of ex Councillor Anton Georgiou the Lib Dems have shown us all how to beat Labour in Brent. The Liberal Democrats got over twice as many votes than Labour in Alperton this time (a ward which still has one Labour Councillor) and have highlighted how to beat Labour in Brent.

Labour love a divided opposition and the fight between the Tories and Reform works in their favour as the right wing anti Labour vote gets split. However if local people get behind Parties who are united and who clearly know how to beat Labour - as the Lib Dems clearly do - then despite their large majority Labour can be beaten and Butt can be kicked out.

Don't forget that there are 57 Councillors in Brent and a party (or a coalition of parties) need just 29 Councillors to be in majority.

The Greens did not stand in Alperton. If sensible 'standing aside' happened in other seats across Brent so that voters had a clear choice of the best placed party to beat Labour - the days of the Butt Leadership would be over. Realistically voting tactically in 2026 is the only way to get it done as the existing Labour Councillors are happy to be bought off with their allowances and will never do the right thing.

Martin Francis said...

Several different sources about his reaction and an email response to bheing told of the resignation where he says: 'Thanks for letting me know. A great start to the new year.'

Anonymous said...

All of our Liib Dem Councillors work hard for local people - unlike the Labour ones who don't even respond.

Anonymous said...

Does Mo Butt have a limit on his tenureship. Surely he must have ??

Anonymous said...

Labour got a kicking, for many reasons, but putting a 19 year old up for election was really odd and a good reason for getting beaten. What connection does she have to the everyday life of residents of Distopian Brent's?

Anonymous said...

How we Brent residents wish this was true. It is rumoured that there was for a moment in time, it is believed he cancelled the recommended changes.

Anonymous said...

Brent residents can easily make a difference by voting Labour out at the next local elections.